As I listened to students share their experiences, it became clear that the way mistakes are handled in the classroom has a big impact on how they feel, how they learn, and how willing they are to participate. Through the five interview questions, I noticed several common themes that kept coming up across all 14 students.

 

 

How Students Feel When They Make Mistakes

Most students told me that making a mistake in math class didn’t feel great, especially at first. Words like embarrassed, frustrated, and nervous came up often. Some students shared that they feared others would think they weren’t smart. But over time, primarily when teachers handled those mistakes with care and didn’t make a big deal, many students started to see their errors as learning moments instead of something to be ashamed of.

​

How Classmates React to Mistakes

Peer reactions played a significant role in students' feelings about making mistakes out loud. Some students described their classmates as supportive, but others mentioned feeling judged, whether through whispers, eye-rolls, or silence. Several said they felt more comfortable speaking up in smaller groups than in front of the whole class. It was clear that even subtle reactions from others could either encourage or shut down participation.

​

How Teachers Handle Mistakes Matters

Students repeatedly shared that their teachers’ reactions made all the difference. When teachers calmly explained what went wrong and made it clear that mistakes are a normal part of learning, students felt more confident about trying, even if they weren’t sure. On the other hand, when teachers just moved on quickly or didn’t acknowledge the effort, students were less likely to speak up next time.

​

When Students Realized Mistakes Help Them Learn

Every student I talked to could recall a specific moment when a mistake helped them understand something better. Sometimes, it happened during a quiz review, other times in group work or class discussion. For many, it was the process of fixing the mistake that helped the learning stick. One student said that redoing an assignment and seeing their improvement convinced them that mistakes could be helpful.

​

Hesitation to Participate

All 14 students admitted that they hesitated to answer a question because they feared being wrong. This wasn’t just something that happened once it came up a lot. Some said they’ve gotten more confident over time, but hesitation still creeps in even then. The fear of being wrong in front of others is accurate, and it affects how students participate.

​

​